If you’ve ever hunted for stylish women’s shoes in larger sizes, you know how challenging it can be—even in a place like New York City, where fashion reigns supreme. 

But don’t stress, I’m here to help you out! Whether you’re rocking a size 11 US (9 UK/43 EU) or something even larger, this guide is all about finding fabulous footwear that fits you perfectly.

Let’s dive into some quick tips to make your NYC shoe-shopping adventure even easier before we hit the stores:

• Know Your Size: U.S. sizes are typically two sizes bigger than UK sizes. For instance, a UK size 9 usually equals a US size 11. Always try on a couple of sizes if possible—brands can vary!
• Check Size Labels: Some shoes list multiple sizing systems. Brands like Clarks, for example, might label a US size 11 as a UK 8.5. Knowing this can save you some confusion.
• Be Sales Tax Savvy: Keep in mind that shoes over $110 are subject to an 8.875% sales tax in NYC—important for your budget!

Ready? Let’s jump into the top stores where you’ll find the best options for large-sized women’s shoes in NYC.

Top New York Stores for Women’s Large-Size Shoes

Nordstrom Rack

If you’re after variety and designer styles at discounted prices, Nordstrom Rack is a fantastic option. They stock sizes up to 12 US (10 UK/44 EU) and organize their shoe department by size, making it easy to browse.

• Locations: Union Square (Downtown Manhattan) and Fulton Street (Brooklyn).
• Pro Tips:
• Union Square has a larger selection, including designer options.
• The Fulton Street branch offers a calmer shopping experience, albeit with a slightly smaller collection.

You’ll find everything from sneakers to stilettos, all ready for you to try on—no waiting for staff to retrieve sizes!

DSW (Designer Shoe Warehouse)

This shoe megastore is a paradise for any shoe lover. While the size 11 US (9 UK) selection can sometimes be limited in-store, their online inventory goes up to size 13 US (11 UK/45 EU).

• Locations: Multiple branches across Manhattan, including one on the Upper West Side.
• Pro Tips:
• Look for bright yellow stickers on shoeboxes—these mark larger sizes.
• Check the clearance section, which is organized by size for easier browsing.

With multiple aisles filled with heels, boots, and more, you’ll have a blast exploring their vast collection.

Macy’s

This iconic department store in Herald Square is a must-visit. The second-floor shoe department is massive, and they often have sale sections arranged by size.

• Pro Tips:
• Swing by the visitor center to grab a 10% discount card.
• Their size 11 US (9 UK) selection is decent, and you’re likely to find something stylish.

Even if you don’t find shoes, the shopping experience at Macy’s is worth the trip.

Bloomingdale’s Outlet

Located on the Upper West Side, Bloomingdale’s Outlet offers a smaller yet curated collection of shoes. While their size 11 US (9 UK) selection isn’t extensive, it’s worth a quick visit for affordable, high-quality finds.

Bentley’s

For an independent boutique vibe, Bentley’s on Montague Street in Brooklyn Heights is a standout. They stock sizes up to 13 US (11 UK/45 EU), catering specifically to women with larger feet.

• What to Expect:
• Affordable prices and a good variety of styles.
• A charming, neighborhood-shop feel.

Pair your shopping trip with a stroll through the picturesque streets of Brooklyn Heights—it’s an experience in itself!

Nordstrom Rack (Fulton Street)

This Brooklyn branch of Nordstrom Rack deserves a second mention for its organized layout and quieter atmosphere. Though the selection might not match Union Square’s, it’s still a great option.

TJ Maxx

Right next to Nordstrom Rack in downtown Brooklyn, TJ Maxx occasionally stocks larger shoe sizes. While it’s hit-or-miss, you might find a hidden gem.

Shopping Tips for Large Sizes

• Online Options: If you don’t find what you’re looking for in-store, many NYC retailers have robust online shops with wider size ranges. Nordstrom Rack, DSW, and Macy’s are all excellent choices for online shopping.
• Specialty Stores: If you’re planning to stay longer, consider looking into niche brands or specialty stores that cater specifically to larger sizes. Some even offer custom-fit options.
• Seasonal Sales: NYC is famous for its holiday and end-of-season sales. These are perfect times to score great deals on shoes in your size.

Final Thoughts

Finding stylish women’s shoes in larger sizes doesn’t have to be frustrating—especially in NYC.

Let me know in the comments if you’ve visited any of these stores or discovered new gems for large-size shoe shopping in NYC. Happy hunting!

Also Read

10 Stores to Buy Extra Wide Size 11 Women's High Heels in the US